UPDATE On Hoboken parking director arrest: Mason criticizes Zimmer’s handling; city responds
Mar 25, 2011 | 2955 views | 7 7 comments | 13 13 recommendations | email to a friend | print
HOBOKEN – Council President Beth Mason, a frequent opponent of the administration of Mayor Dawn Zimmer, took aim at Zimmer and Parking and Transportation Director Ian Sacs on Friday after an alleged incident at City Hall resulted in both Sacs and a city employee being taken to police headquarters in handcuffs.

On Thursday morning, Sacs was allegedly assaulted by a city employee, Bill Laney, and the two were arrested. Laney was charged with simple assault, and Sacs was charged with harassment and theft of property, according to police. Specifics of the arrests have not been released by City Hall.

Other websites have reported that incident occurred after Sacs confiscated the keys to a city bus from Laney, a city bus driver.

City Hall released their version of the incident on Friday, stating: "On his way to work, Director Sacs came across one of the Hop buses left idling, unattended, unlocked, without passengers, and parked illegally on the side of the street. After looking around for the driver unsuccessfully, he returned the unoccupied bus to the City garage as is his responsibility and obligation to the City. Director Sacs then proceeded to bring the keys to the bus back to City Hall."

On Thursday, Zimmer's office released a short statement referring to Sacs as a "victim of workplace violence." On Friday, Zimmer released a new statement. She said: “After yesterday’s incident occurred, my administration immediately began an investigation. Given that this is a personnel matter, it was absolutely essential that the city determine the facts so that we could take appropriate action. All disciplinary decisions were based on direct eye witness accounts provided to the Corporation Counsel’s office.”

Laney was suspended without pay because of the alleged assault, according to the city. Sacs was not suspended.

Mason said in her own statement: “The actions taken yesterday by Mayor Dawn Zimmer and the City Administration in response to an altercation between a city employee and City Parking Authority Director Ian Sacs are very troubling. The mayor’s decision to suspend the employee without pay, while keeping her friend, Mr. Sacs, on the payroll with free legal advice from the corporation counsel, goes beyond any reasonable bounds of fairness."

Zimmer has said a third party investigation will take place to look into the incident. Mason wasn't satisfied.

“The Mayor has called for a ‘third-party investigation’ into this matter,” Mason said. “Before she spends any more tax dollars to defend Mr. Sacs, she should let the Hoboken Police conduct a thorough and objective investigation and let our courts decide where to affix responsibility for this ugly incident.”

Zimmer defended her decisions on Friday.

“As with every personnel matter, our Office of Corporation Counsel conducts a fact-finding investigation before filing administrative charges against an employee,” she said. “We have an obligation to ensure our employees a safe workplace, so while there is a parallel legal process that will proceed through the courts to address summonses issued, there is also a disciplinary process to address employee behavior through the Office of Administrative Law and the Civil Service Commission. As I said yesterday, we have brought in an outside independent party to conduct an investigation of the matter. Michael D’Anton from the law offices of Chasan, Leyner & Lamparello has already begun his investigation, which we expect will conclude in the near future. This firm had previously been approved by the City Council.” -- Ray Smith

Comments
(7)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
WESTY
|
March 27, 2011
Director Sac's accomplishments have also made him a target for the political vitriol from Elizabeth Mason her new majority on the City Council re-election campigns.

Mrs. Mason has a long well established reputation of criticism and obstruction but has not been responsible for much in the of positive accomplishments for her years in office.

Hoboken deservs better.
markorman
|
March 27, 2011
When I moved to Hoboken several years back, I almost voted for Beth Mason for Mayor based on what seemed to be her resposible background as advertised in her camaign literature. Then came her vicious mailer showing a photo of Dawn Zimmer looking goggle-eyed and whacky. This was then followed up by her additional nasty attack campaign literature, which turned me off completely. Since then, she has taken every opportunity to slur Mayor Zimmer for what seems to be essentially personal political ambition, namely her desire for power. I don't know the politics of what's going on in the City Council, but one gets the impression that the attack bullies there who are out to obstruct Zimmer at every opportunity elected Mason president so that they could have a loudmouth do their dirty work for them. I am not part of the political system in this town, and don't know if Mayor Zimmer will ultimately turn out to be a good or bad mayor, but she seems to be trying her best to do the right thing, and is obstructed at every turn by the politically ambition sharks on the City Council. I hope that these types will be thrown out after this upcoming election in May so that we can get a chance to evaluate Mayor Zimmer's successes and failures without the incessant obstructionism of the presaent majority.
DancingRudy
|
March 25, 2011
Khoboken - you're analogy is perfect. Also, what's the deal with the changing charges. As another poster pointed out, first the police announced they're charging Ian with driving without a commercial license, an obviously contrived charge, and now the charge seems to have disappeared. I'll bet there's an interesting story behind who came up with the idea of charging that, and why it was suddenly dropped without comment.
khoboken
|
March 25, 2011
It is a pretty sick trick to try and mae poiticla points out of work place violence.

I posted this elsewhere but it bears repeateing. I was wondering what the reaction would be if the Chief of the FD found a Hoboken FD rescue truck, illegally parked, keys in the ignition, engine running and unlocked, and could not find the firefighter responsible for the vehicle. Would anyone criticize him for taking control of the vehicle, moving it to a secure place and taking the keys with him until he found out what was going on? And when he found the missing fireman, what would people be saying if that fireman assualted the Chief of the FD? Do you think that the any police officer would arrest and handcuff the Chief of the FD for "stealing" the keys and illegally driving the fire vehicle? or for "Harrassment"? Hardly.

BTW, it is more than interesting that Mr. Sacs was not arrested for assualt.
rtrux
|
March 25, 2011
hey beth, here's a novel idea: how about you do something constructive for a change? the only reason someone makes a statement like this is because they don't have any of their own accomplishments to talk about. i live in your ward, how about doing some good for us for a change? geez.

you're up for re-election, how about doing something that makes me want to vote for you again instead of wasting time with this drivel?

greenshirt
|
March 25, 2011
So a Director is allegedly assaulted by an employee and Beth Mason inserts herself for political gain taking sides on the matter.

What a shock, not!

Beth Mason is beneath contempt. Take note 2nd ward voters.
DancingRudy
|
March 25, 2011
What's really startling here is that Mrs. Mason has so little understanding of the process through which personnel decisions are made. To make this simple for her - if my daughter was arrested for something my husband and I would try to figure out what happened and dispense appropriate discipline within our family. This is independent of what might happen with the police matter. That would be my job as a parent and I'm sure Mrs. Mason and her husband would do the same thing with their children. This is what the City must do with the personnel matter, and frankly, this concept is not rocket science. The fact that our City Council President either genuinely doesn't understand this, or is pretending she doesn't understand this, is almost scary.